Saturday, January 12, 2019

Sepia Saturday: The Incorrigible Mr. Bowers


Sepia Saturday challenges bloggers to share family history through old photographs.


This week’s Sepia Saturday prompt focusing on trains and railroad tracks was at first discouraging. After all, I have already written numerous blogs about my family members who worked for the railroad as brakemen, engineers, conductors, machinists, car repairers, firemen, flagmen, and store clerks. I even wrote about several who died while working on the railroad, mostly by falling off a trestle or sustaining head injuries by stumbling over the tracks.

But just this week I stumbled into a NEW story. (Did you see what I just did there? Clever segue, eh?) It’s the short life of a second cousin twice removed named Emanuel Blakey Roach of Port Republic in Rockingham County, Virginia.

Emanuel married Lucy Ann Morris around 1914, and the two settled into the Port Republic neighborhood where he grew up. At least by 1917 he was employed by the Norfolk & Western Railroad. According to the 1920 census, he was a brakeman; in 1930 he was a railroad laborer.

Five years later, Emanuel was dead. His death certificate reports that he fell from a train about 2.5 miles from Charles Town (not to be confused with Charleston), West Virginia. The first report of his death appeared in the Charleston Daily Mail on March 20, 1935.
 
Charleston Daily Mail, 20 Mar 1935
Newspaperarchive.com
Within a week, the story changed significantly.

The Bluefield Daily Telegraph reported on March 28, that a couple was arrested for questioning in the MURDER of Emanuel Roach. They were taken into custody while on a train in Front Royal, Virginia.
 
Bluefield Daily Telegraph 28 Mar 1935
Newspaperarchive.com
More was added to the story the next day. The couple were Richard and Lillie Bowers, alias Austin. Alias? Mrs. Bowers or Mrs. Austin, whoever, said that Emanuel’s death was due “indirectly to her presence in the camp car.” So did he fall accidently? Was he thrown from the car? What did her presence have to do with Emanuel’s death?

A reporter for the Daily News Record in Harrisonburg, Virginia, learned that the initial investigation could not determine whether Emanuel’s death was due to accident or murder. However, Lillie Bowers (or was it Austin?) said that he fell or maybe was pushed when he attempted to attack her. Foul play was not suspected until it was discovered that a watch and money were missing from Emanuel’s belongings.
 
Daily News Record 28 Mar 1935
Newspaperarchive.com
Whether Emanuel actually “attacked” the woman or whether he was protecting his belongings, one must wonder what a nice couple was doing in a camp car in the first place. Were they robbing him or were they just taking advantage of the opportunity to grab a little cash from a man who had fallen off the train?

Reports in the Daily News Record suggest the Bowers-Austins were up to no good all along. It seems Richard Bowers had quite the rap sheet. He had served time in Chattanooga, Tennessee; Washington DC; Louisville, Kentucky; and Harrisonburg, Virginia. Most recently in 1934 he had escaped from Western State Hospital (a psychiatric hospital, earlier known as a lunatic asylum). According to Dr. Joseph Dejarnette, director of Western State, Richard Bowers “is incorrigible.”

An interesting side note to this story is that Dr. Dejarnette was director during the heyday of lobotomies and sterilization of the mentally ill. Maybe Bowers had a good reason to escape. Still, he looks rather guilty in the death of Emanuel Roach.




Daily News Record 29 Mar 1935
Newspaperarchive.com
Stay on track for more old photos and stories aboard the Sepia Saturday train.

Wendy
© 2019, Wendy Mathias. All rights reserved.

20 comments:

  1. What a neat story! You did a great job researching this!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks, Paula. It was a surprise, but it was interesting to me.

      Delete
  2. Very interesting, and now I wonder what really happened...which of course we'll never know.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. That's right. Do you think the papers in Virginia or West Virginia printed anything about the trial? Not that I can find. . . .

      Delete
  3. Poor cousin Roach...wrong place wrong time for meeting up with the 'incorrigible' couple. Interesting the news clippings of the investigation one after the other as the investigation progressed. I, too, had several tragic railroad deaths of ancestors, but went with the one that had the best history.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. It was big news the days following the accident or murder, but I found nothing about the Grand Jury in April. Figures!

      Delete
  4. Hopefully this story continues to full conclusion? Would love to know how it ends! Nice 'cliff hanger'. :)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Oh how I wish, but if there was anything in the papers about the trial, it didn't pop up in Newspaperarchive. I didn't find anything in GenealogyBank or Newspapers.com either.

      Delete
  5. My husband had a similar mystery - it was never confirmed if his 2x great grandmother was murdered in her home or she accidentally fell on the hatchet and cut her head. Seems like a no-brainer to me but things were different 100+ years ago.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Where are the medical examiners and forensics teams when you need them? It is disheartening how often there is no follow up on yesterday's big headlines.

      Delete
  6. So fascinating! I too was curious about the outcome of the grand jury, but reading the comments, I see that nothing else was written. Wonder if they settled it without going to the grand jury and no one thought it was interesting to report that news?

    betty

    ReplyDelete
  7. Wow, a real detective story! And without a photo too! Not a typical Sepia Saturday post. Like the others I'm hoping for a sequel when you reopen this cold case and unravel the mystery.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Ha Ha - yep, busted. When I finished this post, I realized I had NO photo. Do news clippings count? Oh well, I have MULTIPLE photos for next week to make up for this faux pas.

      Delete
  8. A Superb story & neat detective work on your part ('would make a rather good movie me'thinks!)
    Can I share a link here? Reading your post , I rembember a story (its too late to put on my own blog now)about a strange 'death' that happened on the tracks very near where I live.It's about a coffin that fell off a local train. It turned out to be a victim of the Titanic.The ultimate in "adding insult to injury" http://www.hebdenbridgehistory.org.uk/charlestown/events.html

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Oh now that's a wreck! What a co-inky-dinky that the town is also named Charlestown. And yes, adding insult to injury! Bad enough to die in the Titanic disaster, but to be blamed for the train wreck is the ultimate insult.

      Delete
  9. What a story! Glad you are on track with Sepia Saturday again! I miss you when you aren't here!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. And I missed you when you were absent. Thanks!!

      Delete
  10. Well this was really fascinating! Lucky to have found so much interesting information to tie up loose ends.

    ReplyDelete