Showing posts with label Armentrout. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Armentrout. Show all posts

Wednesday, July 22, 2020

52 Ancestors - OLD COUNTRY: From Palatinate to Virginia


I sometimes look at today’s farms in Rockingham County, Virginia and wonder why early immigrants would come here. It’s mountainous. It’s rocky. The soil has a lot of clay. It looks like too much work to overcome for farming. Yet come they did when agents and advertising in colonial Pennsylvania lured German immigrants to Virginia where similar land was much cheaper.
View of Shenandoah Valley from Skyline Drive

In 1751 a representative of the Armentrout family made a trip to the valley of Virginia to check out the claims. He was so impressed with the limestone outcroppings that he entered into a provisional contract to purchase. He then returned to Pennsylvania with glowing reports that Virginia looked just like the home they left in Germany.

That story came back to me a couple years ago during our river cruise along the Danube River from Budapest through the Wachau Valley to Vilshofen, Germany. As I admired the scenery, I couldn’t help thinking, “Yep, these mountains really do look just like the ones in Virginia.” They are low mountains, lush with green trees. They are in sharp contrast to the tall stony, snow-capped Rocky Mountains of America and the Alps of Europe.
 
View during excursion on Danube River Cruise 2017
MEANWHILE BACK IN GERMANY
Virginia is indeed beautiful, so I understand why the German immigrants wanted to settle here. But why did they leave Germany in the first place?

Germans had been immigrating to American colonies since the earliest days. War and plundering of the lower and middle classes alike went on for years and years. Add religious persecution, and it is easy to see why my ancestors would have traded one set of hardships for the unknown. Could it be any worse? While their arrival was decades after William Penn had drawn Germans to his colony with the promise of religious freedom, it seems likely that was still a strong motivation.

Present-day map of Nassau - red marker shows
location of Irmtraut
The Armentrouts were Protestants of the Reformed Faith and were called Palatines, as they were residents of the Palatinate, a small state in the Holy Roman Empire along the Rhine. Today that area is the State of Nassau, Germany. There is even a small farming village by the name of Irmtraut straddling National Route 54. Most certainly my ancestors must have lived at least close by. The first mention of Irmtraut was in 879 when the Germunden Monastery was established.

The name “Irmtraut” means “Friend of the Valkyries” suggesting that members of the family served their liege lords in military service. It is likely, but not proven, that the Armentrouts who arrived in America descended from this old German family.

THE VOYAGE
Once the Armentrouts made their decision to pick up sticks and relocate to America, they would have gathered only the possessions they could carry and traveled down the Rhine to Rotterdam to board the Samuel. The ship made one stop in Deal, England to load supplies and water. On 26 August 1739, 340 passengers arrived at the port of Philadelphia. Disembarking the next day were my ancestors: a widow Anna Elizabeth Ermantraudt (age 40) and her 7 children – Johannes, Anna Elizabeth, Johan Phillip, Johan Friederich, Christopher (or Christople), Johan Heinrich, and Johan George. All males 16 and older were required to sign an Oath of Allegiance to England
 
Signatures of the oldest sons and possibly uncle
Johannes Ermantraudt
Johan Phillip Ermantraudt
Johan Friederich Ermantraudt
Peter Hain 
NOTE: Ermantraudt is the spelling used most often for members born before 1800. The Anglicized spelling is used for those born after. Even then, there are variations.

So where was Anna Elizabeth’s husband? It is not clear whether he died during the voyage or in Europe. A passenger named Peter Hain accompanied the Armentrouts on the trip. It is believed he was Anna Elizabeth’s brother who perhaps had returned to the Palatinate to escort his sister and family. If they wanted or needed an escort, it is very likely that Anna Elizabeth’s husband had died before the trip even began.

LIFE IN PENNSYLVANIA
For a time the Armentrouts lived with George and Veronica Hain until they could get settled and purchase their own land. George was Peter’s older brother. George had immigrated years earlier as part of the English project for settling German Protestants from the refugee camps around London to the Scoharie area of the New York Colony. There the Germans were put to work for the English Navy. Dissatisfied with conditions, many of the Germans left and moved into what is now Berks County, Pennsylvania.

Present-day Wernersville, PA
The oval shows approximately where the Armentrouts lived.
The Hains Church was located on land donated by George Hain.
Probably the Armentrouts were of some means. In less than 10 years, they managed to acquire over 500 acres of some of the best land in present-day Berks County. Yet, they gave it up to move once again to the valley of Virginia.

Source:
Armentrout, Russell S. Armentrout Family History 1739-1978


Amy Johnson Crow continues to challenge genealogy bloggers and non-bloggers alike to think about our ancestors and share a story or photo about them. The challenge is “52 Ancestors in 52 Weeks.”

Wendy
© 2020, Wendy Mathias. All rights reserved.

Sunday, April 20, 2014

52 Ancestors: #16 - Fielding JOLLETT

Amy Johnson Crow of No Story Too Small has issued a challenge:  write one blog post each week devoted to a specific ancestor.  It can be a story, a biography, a photograph, an outline of a research problem – anything that focuses on one ancestor.



The supposed first son of James and Nancy Walker is my direct ancestor, Fielding Jollett, my 3G grandfather.  Since I have already written a great deal about Fielding’s legal problems, I will present “just the facts, ma’am,” but you can read about his exploits here:



Fielding was born sometime between 1795 and 1801 in Orange County, Virginia.  He married Ann Stoutemire/Stoutamoyer on December 7, 1822 in Rockingham County.  They had two known children, but the presence of a second boy under age 5 in the 1830 Rockingham County, Virginia census suggests there may have been a third child.  Ann did not live long.  In fact, she died about 1828.  Perhaps she died in childbirth.

The wife in the 1830 census is Fielding’s second wife, MaryAnn Armentrout, from whom I descend.  Whether the boy was hers or Ann’s is unknown, but he evidently did not live long.  He does not appear after the 1840 census. 

Fielding and Mary Ann had 5 known children.

Mary Ann died January 1870 of Epaulus.  Searches for this term have turned up no definition.  One possibility is that it was a misspelling of a type of skin tumor.
Lucretia Jollett and Thomas Shifflett tombstone McGaheysville, Virginia
Lucretia Jollett and
Thomas Shifflett tombstone
photo courtesy Jan Hensley
Findagrave.com

Following the death of his wife, Fielding lived with his youngest daughter Lucretia and her family in Rockingham County, Virginia, until he died after 1880.  She and her husband are buried in the Mt. Olivet Cemetery in McGaheysville.  It makes sense that Fielding would be there too, but if he is, there is no marker. 

Three Generations:
Fielding JOLLETT (1795 in Orange Co, Virginia - After 1880 in Rockingham Co, Virginia) & m1) Ann STOUTEMIRE  (1795 – Before 1828 Rockingham Co, Virginia)  7 Dec 1822 in Rockingham Co, Virginia ;  & m2) Mary Ann ARMENTROUT (1795 – Jan 1870 Rockingham Co, Virginia) 2 Oct 1828 in Rockingham Co, Virginia

Family of Fielding & Ann Stoutemire JOLLETT:

1. Emanuel JOLLETT  (16 Jun 1824 - 19 Oct 1859 in Rockingham Co, Virginia) & Ann Elizabeth BREEDING/BREEDEN (10 Sep 1824 – After 1870)  4 Jan 1843 in Page County, Virginia
  • Jonathan S. BREEDEN (1839 - ) & Elizabeth MEADOWS (1837 - ) 28 Oct 1858 in Page Co, Virginia
  • Susannah (Susan A.) JOLLETT  (1844 in Page Co, Virginia - ) & Charles W. LONGLEY (1838 Rockingham Co, Virginia – 3 Oct 1864 Elmira, New York)  19 Oct 1862 in Page Co, Virginia
  • Margaret A. JOLLETT (1845 in Page Co, Virginia - )
  • William H. JOLLETT (1847 in Page Co, Virginia - 28 Jun 1924 in Monroe Co, West Virginia) & m1) Mary Elizabeth MARTIN (1845 Warren Co, Virginia - ) 27 Nov 1865 in Warren Co, Virginia ; & m2) Harriet Hattie ECHOLS (28 Sep 1857 – Before 1940) 1 Aug 1876 in Giles Co, Virginia  **aka William P. BOYD
  • Nancy JOLLETT (1850 in Page Co, Virginia - )
  • Sarah E. JOLLETT  (1852 in Page Co, Virginia - )
  • Andrew J. JOLLETT (14 Nov 1855 in Page Co, Virginia - )
  • UNNAMED JOLLETT (27 Aug 1859 in Page Co, Virginia - 27 Aug 1859 Page Co, Virginia)

2. Margaret Ann JOLLETT (19 May 1826 in Rockingham Co, Virginia - 15 Aug 1899 in Oakland, Carroll, Maryland ) & Peter J. NAIR (20 Mar 1819 – 13 Nov 1884) 13 Jan 1845 Rockingham Co, Virginia
  • George NAIR (6 Oct 1845 in Bath County, Virginia - )
  • Thomas J. NAIR (6 Oct 1845 in Bath County, Virginia - 11 Dec 1911) & m1) Elizabeth WINE ( 1839 – Before 7 Sep 1878) ; &  m2) Mary Fanny KINDIG  (Feb 1851 Virginia - ) 7 Sep 1878
  • Mary Jane NAIR (14 Dec 1847 - 11 Aug 1926) & Matthias Buchanan ROSS (1836 – 11 Jul 1898) 9 Jun 1866
  • Robert Franklin NAIR (14 Mar 1848 - Jun 1917) & m1) Susannah HESS ; & m2) Mary Susan SMITH
  • John NAIR  (1849 in Highland Co, Virginia - )
  • Simon Peter NAIR (10 Jun 1849 - 24 Apr 1924)
  • Martha Laura NAIR (1851 Virginia - )
  • Sarah Frances NAIR (19 Mar 1853 - 24 Jan 1930 in Loch Lynn, Ohio) & John Wesley CALHOUN (Sep 1851 - )
  • Melvina NAIR (1858 in Highland Co, Virginia - 18 Feb 1860 Rockingham Co, Virginia)
  • Bellzora NAIR  (1 Oct 1859 in Rockingham County, Virginia - ) & Charles MCROBIE
  • Malinda NAIR (1861 in Virginia - )
  • William J. NAIR (1867 in Highland Co, Virginia - ) & Mary Ellen SMITH
  • Alpharetta NAIR  (1869 in Virginia - )
  • Ruhamiah A. B. NAIR (1872 in Maryland – 1918) & Ellis Rizer SHROUT (17 Nov 1869 – 1935) 19 Mar 1892
Family of Fielding & Mary Ann Armentrout JOLLETT:

1. Lydia Catherine JOLLETT  (26 Apr 1830 in Rockingham Co, Virginia – After  1910) & George Washington BREEDEN (1825 – 1910) on 19 Oct 1846 in Page Co, Virginia
  • Josiah BREEDEN (1847 in Page Co, Virginia - Before 1900) &  Mary Susan Polly PATTERSON (1854 – After 1930) 3 Jan 1876
  • James Madison BREEDEN  (Jan 1851 in Page Co, Virginia – 1915) & Sarah Eliza MEADOWS (May 1841 – 1917)
  • John F. BREEDEN (1 Apr 1853 Page Co, Virginia - 3 Oct 1889 Augusta Co, Virginia) & Mary S. UNKNOWN
  • Fielding L. BREEDEN (26 Oct 1857 Page Co, Virginia - 23 Mar 1865 Page Co, Virginia)
  • Mary Catherine BREEDEN (1858 – After 1930 Washington) & George CARPENTER (1850 Greene Co, Virginia – Before 1930 Washington) 12 Feb 1880 Rockingham Co, Virginia
  • Elijah Nicholas BREEDEN (Apr 1864 -26 Dec 1928 Rockingham Co, Virginia) & Christina Catherine SELLERS (2 Sep 1859 Rockingham Co, Virginia – 4 mar 1940 Rockingham Co, Virginia) 4 Oct 1884 Rockingham Co, Virginia
  • Berryman Suel BREEDEN (1869 - 15 Jul 1876 Rockingham Co, Virginia)
  • Charles Wesley BREEDEN (5 May 1872 – 1938) & m1) Mollie F. WILLIAMS on 12 Oct 1893 in Rockingham Co, Virginia ; & m2) Lucy CRAWFORD on 01 Jun 1926

2. John Wesley JOLLETT  (6 Apr 1832 in Rockingham Co, Virginia - 18 Oct 1916 in Page Co, Virginia) & Sarah Elizabeth SMITH (22 May 1834 in Rockingham Co, Virginia - 30 Jan 1917 in Page Co, Virginia) 21 Feb 1853 in Rockingham Co, Virginia
  • Artubine Joseph JOLLETT (16 Dec 1853 Page Co, Virginia - 27 Oct 1862 Page Co, Virginia)
  • Mary E. V. JOLLETT  (1854 Page Co, Virginia - Before 1901 Page Co, Virginia) & Hiram Franklin MEADOWS (14 Sep 1849 - 22 Feb 1911 Page Co, Virginia) 8 Mar 1870 Page Co, Virginia **aka Marietta V.
  • Matilda Catherine JOLLETT (16 Feb 1858 Page Co, Virginia - 24 Jan 1953 Page Co, Virginia) & Thomas Wesley MEADOWS (15 Jan 1854 Page Co, Virginia - 4 Feb 1941 Page Co, Virginia)  7 Dec 1873 Page Co, Virginia
  • John B. JOLLETT (30 Jan 1867 Page Co, Virginia - After 1940 Baltimore, Maryland) & m1) Fannie Bell GRIFFITH  (Mar 1872 – Before 1940) 13 Dec 1883 ; & m2) Carrie M. UNKNOWN (1894 Maryland - )
  • Charles Belsin Lewis JOLLETT (29 Aug 1871 Page Co, Virginia - 15 Jan 1939 Portsmouth, Virginia) & Nannie June FOGG (Aug 1872 Rappahannock Virginia – 30 Jun 1947 Portsmouth, Virginia) 24 Jun 1890 Page Co, Virginia 

3. Henry Harvey JOLLETT (26 Jul 1834 Rockingham Co, Virginia – 1850 Page Co, Virginia)

4. James Franklin JOLLETT  (17 Nov 1836 Rockingham Co, Virginia - 3 Jun 1930 Augusta Co, Virginia) & m1) Lucy Ann SHIFLETT (1843 Greene Co, Virginia - 1884 Monroe, Greene, Virginia) 12 Nov 1859 in Greene Co, Virginia ; & m2) Eliza Jane COLEMAN (17 Jan 1856 Greene Co, Virginia - 9 Dec 1938 Augusta Co, Virginia) 29 Aug 1885 Greene Co, Virginia

Family of James Franklin & Lucy Ann Shiflett JOLLETT:
  • Burton Lewis JOLLETT  (1860 in Virginia – Before 5 May 1934 in Greene Co, Virginia) & m1) Louisa SULLIVAN (1861 – 1900) 20 Jan 1881 ; & m2) Cornelia MORRIS (Nov 1844 – Before 1920) 19 Sep 1900 Greene Co, Virginia
  • Emma F. JOLLETT (1 Feb 1863 Greene Co, Virginia - 10 Apr 1945 in Shenandoah, Page, Virginia) &  Andrew Jackson COLEMAN (29 Jul 1858 Greene Co, Virginia – 4 Oct 1947 Shenandoah, Page, Virginia) 26 Nov 1880 Greene Co, Virginia
  • Laura E. JOLLETT (30 May 1865 Greene Co, Virginia - 30 Jul 1947 Shenandoah, Page, Virginia) & William J. SULLIVAN (13 Jan 1866 – 22 May 1942 Shenandoah, Page, Virginia) 14 Jan 1886 Greene Co, Virginia
  • Columbia Ann Leanna JOLLETT (14 Mar 1867 Greene Co, Virginia - 20 Sep 1936 Greene Co, Virginia) & James Mitchell KNIGHT (9 May 1866 Greene Co, Virginia – 16 Feb 1942 Greene Co, Virginia) 1 Mar 1885 Greene Co, Virginia
  • Mary Frances JOLLETT (10 Jan 1870 Greene Co, Virginia - 22 Feb 1950 Harrisonburg, Rockingham, Virginia) & Walter Beriah Sylvester DAVIS (12 Sep 1867 Rockingham Co, Virginia - 31 Oct 1934 Shenandoah, Page, Virginia) 11 Feb 1890 in Greene Co, Virginia 
  • Sarah Catherine Sallie JOLLETT (11 May 1872 Greene Co, Virginia  - 7 Jul 1944 Washington DC) & George Thomas CLIFT (Sep 1865 Virginia - ) 30 Mar 1891
  • Victoria Elizabeth JOLLETT (19 Mar 1878 Greene Co, Virginia - 2 May 1944) & Decatur Bainbridge BREEDEN (15 Sep 1877 – 27 Sep 1952 Washington DC) about 1902
  • William Isaac JOLLETT  (Jan 1880 Greene Co, Virginia - Jul 1903 Newport News, Virginia)=
  • Ulysses Finks JOLLETT (26 Jan 1883 Greene Co, Virginia - 30 Jan 1931 Baltimore, Maryland) & Sadie Janiero LAMB 23 Nov 1903 Greene Co, Virginia

Family of James Franklin & Eliza Coleman JOLLETT:
  • James Henry JOLLETT  (Apr 1894 Augusta Co, Virginia - 1909 Augusta Co, Virginia)

5. Lucretia  JOLLETT (18 Sep 1838 Rockingham Co, Virginia - 31 Dec 1911 Rockingham Co, Virginia) & m1) Jacob Haskell SHIFLETT (1836 Greene Co, Virginia – Before 1871) 5 Aug 1858 in Page Co, Virginia ; & m2) Thomas S. SHIFLETT (1839 Albemarle Co, Virginia – 16 Jan 1924 Rockingham Co, Virginia) 8 Oct 1871 Greene Co, Virginia

Family of Lucretia JOLLETT & Jacob Haskell SHIFLETT:
  • Mary E. SHIFLETT  (May 1859 - Before 1955) &  George Remington MAYHEW (Jul 1847 New York - ) 17 Mar 1879 Page Co, Virginia,
  • Martha F. S. SHIFLETT (1863 - Before 1955) George W. MCCAULEY (Aug 1852 – Before 1920) 8 Jun 1882 Rockingham Co, Virginia
Family of Lucretia JOLLETT & Thomas SHIFLETT:
  • James William Newton Will SHIFLETT (16 Apr 1873 - 2 Mar 1955 Rockingham Co, Virginia) & m1) Phenie BERRY (1881 – Before 1902) 18 Jul 1901 Rockingham Co, Virginia ; & m2) Sudie Belle LIFE (Jul 1885 – 28 Mar 1950 Rockingham Co, Virginia) 17 Dec 1902 Rockingham Co, Virginia
  • John Thomas Sylvester Sell SHIFLETT (19 Oct 1876 Rockingham Co, Virginia - 10 Mar 1958 Rockingham Co, Virginia) & m1) Annie Laura MEADOWS  (1880 – 27 Dec 1898) 13 Dec 1898 Rockingham Co, Virginia ; & m2 ) Margaret JOHNSON (25 Nov 1862 Rockingham Co, Virginia – 27 Dec 1954 Rockingham Co, Virginia) 14 Dec 1901 Rockingham Co, Virginia
  • Aaron SHIFLETT (Apr 1891 Rockingham County, Virginia - )



© 2014, Wendy Mathias.  All rights reserved.

Monday, July 22, 2013

Mystery Monday: Forum Brings Hope

Mystery Monday is a daily prompt at Geneabloggers encouraging bloggers to share mystery ancestors or mystery records – anything which is currently unsolved.  With any luck fellow genealogy bloggers will lend their eyes to what has been found so far and possibly help solve the mystery.


Following the suggestion of fellow-blogger Jacqi Stevens, I recently posted a query in the Lingle Genforum and in the Rockingham County, Virginia forum on Rootsweb.  I stated that I am trying to confirm John and Elizabeth Lingle Armentrout as parents of Mary Ann Armentrout, my 3G grandmother who was married to Fielding Jollett.  I referenced Martin and Anna Maria Lingle Schneider/Snyder as sponsors at the baptism of “Maria Armentrout.” 

Within an hour of posting on Rootsweb, I heard from Jan Hensley, a dedicated researcher of families in Rockingham County, with whom I have collaborated from time to time on Jollett and Sampson research.  She provided a couple more pieces to the puzzle.

First of all, Jan told me about a chancery cause in Rockingham County between Emanuel Hansberger and Charles Yancey (1835-002) that lists the descendants of Jacob Lingle, the first.  Elizabeth is listed as the daughter of Jacob Lingle, the second.  It states further that she “married John Armentrout of Rockingham, the said John is dead but the said Elizabeth is still living.”

Why I like this clue:  even though it does not list Elizabeth’s children, John’s being dead before 1835 is consistent with the fact that in 1837 Mary Ann and Fielding sold the land she had inherited from her father “John Armentrout, deceased.”

Second, Jan added that also listed among the children of Jacob Lingle, the second, is Elizabeth’s sister Mary who married Martin Snyder.  From the chancery cause, “Martin Snyder and Mary his wife are both dead leaving children and heirs Barbara Snyder who has since intermarried with a certain Philip Parrat of Rockingham, Elizabeth who married a certain Christian Sellers and removed to the state of Indiana, Mathias Snyder of Rockingham, and Catherine who married a certain Jacob Freeze of Rockingham….”

Why I like this clue:  For the first time, I see “Anna Maria Schneider” Anglicized as “Mary.”  Keeping my fingers crossed that the German custom of naming a child for the sponsor at baptism has held true in the case of my Mary Ann.

And finally, in subsequent emails, Jan encouraged me to “follow the land,” to pin down any clues that might be in deeds.  When I casually added that I would also follow up on the sale of Mary Ann’s inherited land to Henry Kisling, Jan told me this:  that Christina Lingle, the sister of Jacob Lingle, the second, married Christopher Kisling and that Henry was their son. 

Why I like this clue:  Isn’t it obvious?  Fielding and Mary Ann Armentrout Jollett must have sold the land to her COUSIN.  The Armentrout-Snyder-Lingle-and now Kisling connection gets stronger and stronger.  

Yes, it’s circumstantial.  But in the court of law, enough circumstantial evidence is enough to convict. But in the world of genealogy, the jury is still out.




© 2014, Wendy Mathias.  All rights reserved.

Monday, July 15, 2013

Mystery Monday: A Stumble in the Search for Mary Ann

Mystery Monday is a daily prompt at Geneabloggers encouraging bloggers to share mystery ancestors or mystery records – anything which is currently unsolved.  With any luck fellow genealogy bloggers will lend their eyes to what has been found so far and possibly help solve the mystery.


My study of the 1810 Rockingham County, Virginia census thrilled me with the possibility of finally discovering the parents of Mary Ann Armentrout, second wife of my 3G grandfather Fielding Jollett.  I had hoped the 1820 census would add weight to my theory.  However, it does nothing for it although it doesn’t hurt either.

1820 Rockingham County, VA Census with John Armentrout































Why?  Because somebody had the bright idea to alphabetize the census rather than list residents geographically which would have preserved the neighbor connection that is so useful in finding relatives, particularly women whose names just disappeared upon marriage.

But on the plus side, John is still there (with his last name spelled “Armentrought”), with a household that resembles the one from 1810, only 10 years older.


1810
1820
Males under 10
-
1 – possibly John Jr. (1816)
Males 10 - 16
-
-
Males 16 - 18
-
-
Males 16 - 26
-
-
Males 26 - 45
-
-
Males over 45
1 – John Armentrout
1 – John Armentrout
Females under 10
1 – possibly Linda (1805)
-
Females 10 - 16
1 – possibly Elizabeth (1798)
1 – possibly Linda (1805)
Females 16 - 26
1 – possibly Maria (1795)
2 – possibly Elizabeth (1798)
and possibly Maria (1795)
Females 26 - 45
-
-
Females over 45
1 – Elizabeth Lingle Armentrout
1 – Elizabeth Lingle Armentrout

The 1830 census shows no John Armentrout in Rockingham County.  It’s possible he had moved to a different county, he was living in someone else’s household - maybe one of his children’s, or he had died.  At any rate, in 1837, Mary Ann Armentrout and Fielding Jollett sold some land she had inherited from her late father John.

Feeling that my leads had dried up, I recalled a recent blogpost by Jacqi Stevens at A Family Tapestry.  In her series on using social media in genealogy, she reminded me that even the old stand-bys like Rootsweb and Genforum are a form of social media, albeit “low-tech.”  So off to Genforum and Rootsweb I went in search of surname forums and information on the Lingles, my most likely candidate for a mother for Mary Ann. 

Fortunately there had been an inquiry related to Jacob Lingle, Elizabeth’s father.  UNfortunately, the thread was old – like 2001 old.  Still I dashed off an email to 2 of the respondents on the thread.  The AOL email bounced back.  The email to the Juno account is still out there.  Juno!!  Juno??  Who uses that anymore?  Is it even still around?  Hmm – that might come back too.

But in that dusty thread was a shiny nugget.  The original poster said her ancestor was Barbara Snyder, daughter of Martin Snyder/Schneider and Anna Maria LINGLE.  This is the same couple that served as sponsors at the baptism of Maria Armentrout, the one I HOPE was later known as Mary Ann.  The Schneiders were not doing just a neighborly favor for John and Elizabeth Armentrout; there was a family bond.

I admit it’s just another little tidbit that amounts to nothing in the quest to pin down Mary Ann’s parents.  Maybe it’s time I try to revive that Lingle surname forum with a little inquiry of my own.



© 2014, Wendy Mathias.  All rights reserved.

Monday, July 8, 2013

Mystery Monday: One Step Closer in the Search for Mary Ann

Mystery Monday is a daily prompt at Geneabloggers encouraging bloggers to share mystery ancestors or mystery records – anything which is currently unsolved.  With any luck fellow genealogy bloggers will lend their eyes to what has been found so far and possibly help solve the mystery.
As soon as I saw John and Elizabeth Lingle Armentrout with 4 children (including Maria) listed in the “Miscellaneous” chapter of the Armentrout Family History by Russell S. Armentrout, I went to work.

1810 Rockingham County, Virginia Federal Census
Click to enlarge

In studying the 1810 Rockingham County, Virginia Census, I noticed John Armantrout (Ermentraudt/Armentrout) was a neighbor of George Armantrout and near neighbor of Augustine Armantrout, both known sons of Johan Friederich Ermentraudt, the most likely candidate for father of “my” John Armentrout.

Since they were close in age, they look like brothers:


John
George
Augustine
Males under 10
-
1
3
10 – 16
-
-
-
16 - 26
-
-
1
26 - 45
-
-
-
Over 45
1
1
1
Females under 10
1
2
-
10 - 16
1
-
1
16 - 26
1
-
-
26 - 45
-
1
1
Over 45
1
-
-


The ages of the girls line up with the names identified with this John Armentrout family:

  • 16-26 - Maria born 1795
  • 10-16 - Elizabeth born 1798
  • Under 10 - Linda born 1805
  • Over 45 – John’s wife Elizabeth Lingle Armentrout
The fact that there were no male children makes sense since young John was not born until 1816.

Likewise, the ages match what is known of George’s family:

  • Male under 10 – Michael born 1807
  • Females under 10 – Barbara born 1806, and Magdalena born 1809
  • Female 26-45 – George’s wife Elizabeth Michael Armentrout

And Augustine’s family:

  • Males under 10 – Emanual born 1801, Charles born 1805, and Frederick born 1808
  • 16-26 – John George born 1793
  • Female 10-16 - ? Magdalena would have been about 19 but she also was married before 1810 and likely out of the house.  Possibly this is another child for whom other records have not been found.
  • Female 26-45 – Augustine’s wife Margaret Schneider Armentrout.

What makes all this even more compelling are the other near neighbors.  These names appear together on the SAME page of a 31-page census recorded by Daniel Bryan for Rockingham County. 

  • Jacob Lingle
  • Jacob Lingle (senior)
  • Martin Snyder/Schneider
  • Jacob Stoutemire

Using the theory that people dated and married within a three-mile radius, I conclude that the two Jacob Lingles must be the father and brother of Elizabeth Lingle who married John Armentrout.  Is it possible?  Let’s see:



John
Jacob
Jacob Sr.
Males under 10
-
2
-
10 – 16
-
1
-
16 - 26
-
-
-
26 - 45
-
1
-
Over 45
1
-
1
Females under 10
1
3
-
10 - 16
1
-
-
16 - 26
1
-
-
26 - 45
-
1
-
Over 45
1
-
1

Obviously John and younger Jacob are of the same generation with children of similar age while Jacob Sr. and his wife are empty-nesters.  Of course, without DNA or at least a marriage record or other document, this is conjecture, but a pretty strong one anyway.

Like a good neighbor, Martin Snyder/Schneider and his wife were the sponsors at the baptism of John and Elizabeth Lingle Armentrout’s daughter Maria, the one I hope was the woman later known as Mary Ann. 

So what about Jacob Stoutemire?  What does he contribute to the solution to the mystery?  The answer reads like the Six Degrees of Kevin Bacon game, so pay attention:

  • Jacob Stoutemire was the father of Ann Stoutemire.
  • Ann Stoutemire married Fielding Jollett in 1822, but she died before 1828.
  • In 1828 Fielding married his second wife, Mary Ann Armentrout.
  • Mary Ann was the daughter of a John Armentrout. 

This scenario satisfies my curiosity about how Fielding might have met Mary Ann when his farm, which bordered the Stoutemire line, was in Naked Creek while Mary Ann’s family seemed to be closer to McGaheysville.  The theory of the 3-mile dating circle is also reinforced if it turns out that Maria and Mary Ann are the same person and that John and Elizabeth Lingle Armentrout are my 4G grandparents.

Theories!  Everybody has one.  The trick is to make this circumstantial evidence stick, and that will mean proving Maria and Mary Ann are the same person.  Or that possibly Mary Ann is another daughter.  After all, there is a sizeable gap between the births of Elizabeth and Linda and between Linda and John. 

Just for once it would be nice if my family would be predictable:  follow tradition, stay close to one another, leave a trail.  Is that too much to ask?




© 2014, Wendy Mathias.  All rights reserved.